Beli is the app where diners rank restaurants against each other, and the crowd hands back a number. I keep my own numbers, one dinner at a time, on a map with 311 pins. I pulled the Beli score for twelve of them and lined them up.
Here’s what came back. At the top, we mostly agree. Where we split, it’s almost never about the food. It’s about the hype.
All twelve are below. Beli numbers are as of November 2026.
1. Peter Luger Steak House — me 9.0 · Beli 9.0 The famous one, and the one where Beli and I are on the same side. The New York Times took away all of Luger’s stars in 2019. My verdict hasn’t moved: “Quite simply (when you roll food & experience into it) the best steakhouse in North America. The burger is an experience at lunch, and the bacon is a must-have, but go for the traditional dinner — STEAK.” We’re dead even. The paper is the outlier here, not either of us.
THE HYPE SIDE: where the crowd likes it more
2. 4 Charles Prime Rib — me 4.0 · Beli 9.6 A 5.6-point gap, the biggest on the list that isn’t a walkout. “NOT as good as its reputation or the hype; hard to get because there are only 12 tables and the hype. HACK: Go to Au Cheval, easier to get a table and the same food!”
3. Cosme — me 6.0 · Beli 8.3 Three NYTimes stars in 2015. “Fine. Loud. Fancy more for the sake of being fancy — I don’t need to go back.”
4. Kyu — me 6.5 · Beli 8.2 My whole verdict, unedited: “Wish it was better. It’s not.”
5. ABC Kitchen — me 6.0 · Beli 7.4 “If you’re in the neighborhood, fine, if not, absolutely nothing special.”
MY SIDE: where I’m higher than the crowd
6. Karczma — me 8.9 · Beli 7.6 Greenpoint. “Fell in love with the very traditional Polish spot - EVERYTHING is amazing, and I never knew real sauerkraut could be good!” I couldn’t find a critic review.
7. Won Jo — me 9.0 · Beli 7.8 “In K-town but casual and fantastic Korean food. Atmosphere is additive!”
8. Fedora — me 9.0 · Beli 8.5 The original closed in the pandemic. In April 2025 the group behind St. Jardim reopened it with the same name, in the same spot, under the original 1950s neon sign. “Discreet, speakeasy feel, romantic (take that someone special - I did!), and incredible food.”
9. Commerce Inn — me 9.0 · Beli 8.6 “Great for fall and winter, the building is several hundred years old, and the food is simply wonderful + great drinks.”
WHERE WE AGREE (the anchors)
10. Torrisi — me 10.0 · Beli 9.4 My only 10 in this group. Beli has it near the top too.
11. Don Angie — me 9.0 · Beli 9.2 “Insanely good…too many dishes to name but the lasagna !!!” Two-tenths apart.
THE CLOSER
12. The Corner Store — me 0.0 · Beli 9.3 The widest gap I have with anyone: 9.3 points. My verdict, as it reads on the map: “If you are an influencer or want to dine with celebrities, go. If you appreciate good food and a wonderful dining experience – I wouldn’t. All Hype and no substance.”
It isn’t my only zero. Beefbar in Tribeca has one too (no Beli score to compare): “on the list of the worst, most overpriced restaurants in the city – hype only and barely - it’s a joke.”
I leave both zeros up. A Map that only shows the wins isn’t a map. It’s an ad.
What the twelve say
Beli and I agree on the top three: Torrisi, Don Angie, Peter Luger. The disagreements live in two places. Rooms that are hard to get into (4 Charles, The Corner Store) get a scarcity bump from the crowd, not the plate. Places without the buzz (Karczma, Won Jo) get underrated.
A crowd score tells you what people were excited to post. A one-person score tells you what one person would book again, and you can check that person’s record. Every number on my map is from a real visit, dated, and the misses stay up.
All 311 pins (as of November 6th), 206 of them scored, are on The MAP
Your turn: name the place where you and the crowd disagree. One line: the spot, your number, theirs.
The Long Table — food, restaurants, and the New York that survives at the table. My taste, not a star rating. This is my experience and my palate, not a critic’s star rating. Reasonable people love restaurants I found merely fine, and that’s the correct outcome.
Open Tab → I dove deeper: the full, filterable NYC restaurant Map — the comprehensive one, not the argument — is LIVE now for paid subscribers.
A 311-pin map scored 0–10, and I leave the misses up where you can see them. No ads, no sponsors, no press meals — nobody pays for my opinion. You do. The full map is at opentabs.readopentabs.com/TheMap.



I'll go first.
The Corner Store: me 0.0, the crowd 9.3.
Your turn — one line: the spot, your number, and theirs...